Zoom image: 2023 Desmond Competition First Row: Left to Right: Katherine Kio '25 & Tyler Myszka '25 (Winning Team), Victoria Heist '24 & Lexi Horton '24 (Runner-up Team), Haley Case '24, Buffalo Moot Court Board President Second Row: Left to Right: Prof. John Giammatteo; Prof. Lucinda M. Finley, Frank G. Raichle Professor of Trial and Appellate Advocacy; Director of Moot Courts, Sean C. Eldridge '10, U.S. Attorney, U.S. Attorney's Office, WDNY 2023 Desmond Competition First Row: Left to Right: Katherine Kio '25 & Tyler Myszka '25 (Winning Team), Victoria Heist '24 & Lexi Horton '24 (Runner-up Team), Haley Case '24, Buffalo Moot Court Board President Second Row: Left to Right: Prof. John Giammatteo; Prof. Lucinda M. Finley, Frank G. Raichle Professor of Trial and Appellate Advocacy; Director of Moot Courts, Sean C. Eldridge '10, U.S. Attorney, U.S. Attorney's Office, WDNY

The Desmond Competition

For over three decades, this intramural competition gives participants the opportunity to argue a constitutional law case related to matters currently pending before the United States Supreme Court.

The Charles S. Desmond Moot Court Competition is the most prestigious appellate advocacy competition at the law school, attracting several local lawyers and judges to volunteer their time as judges.  Accomplished lawyers from Western New York and law school professors judge competitors’ oral arguments in the preliminary and semi-final rounds, while federal and state judges evaluate the finalists. Competitors also submit a written brief formatted using the rules to the United States Supreme Court.

Organized by the School of Law's Buffalo Moot Court Board, the Desmond competition is one of the most popular courtroom competitions the school offers. The competition is open to all second-and third-year law students annually.

2025 Competition Results

Winning Team: Brooklynn Flowers ‘27 and Nicholas Liberty ‘27

Finalists: Bella DeFeo ‘27 and Jenna Peinkofer ‘27

Best Oralist in the Final Round: Brooklynn Flowers ‘27

Best Individual Oralist (Preliminary Rounds)

  • 1st: Jenna Peinkofer ‘27
  • 2nd: Luke Bailey ‘27
  • 3rd: Brooklynn Flowers ‘27

Best Brief (Preliminary Rounds)

  • Brooklynn Flowers ‘27 and Nicholas Liberty ‘27
  • Brandon Barthold ‘27 and Aidan Comerford ‘27
  • Maxwell Battaglia ‘26 and Francesca Manzella ‘26

Judges for Final Round:  Hon. Jeremiah J. McCarthy, Hon. Susan M. Eagan '96, and Professor Lucinda Finley

Buffalo Moot Court Board Leadership

President: Maeve Christ
Vice-President: Gavin Zmuda
Treasurer: Hunter Siegel
Public Relations Directors: Sarah Jiva and Emily Rasulo

Faculty Adviser: Prof. Lucinda Finley

Contact: law-bmcb@buffalo.edu
Find us in: Instagram, UBLinked, Website